Photo: Ka23 13 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0
A court challenge to South Africa’s telecoms ownership rules has reopened a central debate over transformation, investment and access to digital infrastructure.
The legal challenge
Business lobby group Sakeliga has filed an application in the Pretoria High Court seeking a review of the communications regulator ICASA’s position that individual telecoms licence holders must have at least 30% ownership by historically disadvantaged groups.
DGBN has also reported on Scott Colom becomes Mississippi’s first Black US senator since Reconstruction.
The case, filed on 9 November, targets ICASA’s decision of 13 May. Sakeliga argues that the Electronic Communications Act does not make a 30% equity stake the only permissible way for companies to meet empowerment conditions.
Instead, it says the regulator should be able to recognise equity-equivalent investment programmes. These can include spending on skills, enterprise development, local supply chains and digital infrastructure rather than transferring share ownership.
Sakeliga is also asking for a constitutional ruling if the court finds the law does make the 30% ownership threshold compulsory. No ruling has been made.
ICASA says Parliament must act
ICASA has maintained that it is bound by the Electronic Communications Act, which it says requires a minimum 30% ownership by historically disadvantaged groups for individual licence holders.
In May, the regulator said it could not fully align its licensing rules with the ICT Sector Code’s equity-equivalent programmes without Parliament amending the law. The position followed a December 2025 policy direction from Communications Minister Solly Malatsi urging ICASA to consider that alignment.
For more context, read DGBN’s coverage of Africa presses COP31 to turn climate pledges into energy investment.

The legal dispute therefore turns on interpretation: whether the existing legislation already gives ICASA discretion to approve alternative empowerment mechanisms, or whether legislative reform is required first.
Why Starlink is part of the debate
The case has particular significance for Starlink, the satellite internet company owned by SpaceX. Starlink has not secured the licences needed to sell services directly in South Africa, while SpaceX has resisted the local ownership requirement.
But the outcome could affect a far wider group of existing and prospective network operators, internet providers and broadcasters. It could also shape conditions for firms such as Amazon Leo, Eutelsat OneWeb and others considering direct services in the country.
Telkom has separately criticised ICASA’s ownership regulations in a submission to the regulator, saying they go beyond the broader B-BBEE framework and may deter investment. However, Telkom says any alternative model must apply equally to established operators and new entrants, rather than creating a separate regulatory route for satellite companies.
Why this matters
For Black South Africans, the case goes to the heart of who benefits from a sector built on a scarce public resource: radio spectrum. Black economic empowerment rules were created to address exclusion from ownership and opportunity under apartheid.
Supporters of the current regime see the 30% requirement as an essential safeguard for meaningful participation in a strategic industry. Critics argue that flexible, enforceable investment commitments could widen broadband access and draw more capital into underserved communities.
Related DGBN reporting includes Digital Africa Summit returns to Cape Town with policy, AI and connectivity in focus.
For wider context, see Ivory Coast 0-1 Cameroon: Nsongo wins it for the Indomitable Lions on Diajem Sports Network.
The court’s eventual decision will not automatically grant any company a licence. It could, however, determine whether South Africa’s telecoms transformation goals must be met through ownership alone or can also be pursued through alternative investment obligations.

